What “Not” To Be Thankful For On A Day For Giving Thanks
Posted by Michelle Moquin on 25th November 2010
So…Today is Thanksgiving. But what does it really mean to those that it gives great meaning to? The definition of Thanksgiving is a far different description depending on who is telling the story: The whites or the Indians.
To the whites, Thanksgiving was a day that the Pilgrims sat with the indians and agreed to be peaceful. A day of celebration.
To the Wampanoags, Thanksgiving was literally about gratitude for genocide. A day of sorrow.
While we celebrate, sitting around watching football, eating turkey, corn, and all the fixins, toasting and giving thanks, Native Americans remember the massacre. They are not celebrating; they are feeling hurt and disrespected to say the very least, and rightly so.
As Darryl Lorenzo Wellington wrote:
“Spare me the school-assembly version of Thanksgiving. Since I was in grammar school, I’ve seen these misleading re-enactments. The Thanksgiving plays and celebrations glamorize the relationship between the Pilgrims and American Indians. They falsely portray the Pilgrims as the ones who allowed the indians to sup with them, rather than vice versa.”
“And they erase the genocide against Indians that followed.”
-Darryl Lorenzo Wellington is a writer for Progressive Media Project
To read more click here.
Yes, there is a lot to be thankful for, but Thanksgiving is not the day to be thankful when the definition of the traditional Thanksgiving is more fiction than fact; when we ignorantly celebrate peace honoring a day of devastation.
I can tell you what I am not thankful for on this day:
- I am not thankful that people feast on turkey and stuffing in celebration, and many probably don’t really know the devastating truth about Thanksgiving, the massacre of indigenous people. And if they do, it is even more disgusting that they are still celebrating.
- I am not thankful that a supposed day of giving thanks is really gratitude for genocide.
- I am not thankful that Pilgrims didn’t invite the Indians to feast with them peacefully, but instead Pilgrims perceived Indians in relation to the Devil and the only reason why they were invited to that feast was for the purpose of negotiating a treaty that would secure the lands for the Pilgrims.
- I am not thankful that 700 Pequot men, women and children were massacred on this day known for giving thanks.
- I am not thankful that the Governor of Massachusetts Bay Colony declared: “A day of Thanksgiving, thanking God that they had eliminated over 700 men, women and children.” It was signed into law that, “This day forth shall be a day of celebration and thanksgiving for subduing the Pequots.”
- I am not thankful that “Thanksgiving dinner” was invented both to instill a false pride in Americans and to cover up the massacre.
- I am not thankful that when the Pilgrims arrived, the Pequot tribe numbered 8,000 but disease had brought their numbers down to 1,500 by 1637. The Pequot “War” killed all but a handful of remaining members of the tribe. FYI: The disease was smallpox, brought to the indians through infected blankets, and flu-filled flannel gifts, that were giving to them by the Pilgrims.
- I am not thankful that the first Official Thanksgiving was gratitude for genocide in 1637, and in 1676 – 1677 “a day was set apart for public Thanksgiving,” because nearly all of the indians were exterminated by then.
- I am not thankful that America was basically founded on MASS genocide…a genocide of up to as many as 3 million plus indians.
- I am not thankful that when taking into consideration that the slaughter of indians started in 1492 with Christopher Columbus, “and has continued to a certain degree to this day, the number of our Peoples who died, and in many cases who are still dying, because of the European invasion Columbus initiated, is incalculable.” One can estimate the closest number is several hundred millions.
To read ”The Real Thanksgiving” by Dr. Daniel Paul, click here.
Readers: Celebrating Thanksgiving is no different than honoring the Confederate flag, or honoring the Germans for the putting Jews in the oven.
How easy it is for us to build a holocaust museum that condemns Germans; there are several. And yet it is another issue to build a museum that confronts our own genocide. Can you imagine a museum that confronts the genocide that was perpetrated by our own ancestors towards Native Americans or towards African-Americans? It just isn’t going to happen, probably ever.
Even in Washington, the Native American museum doesn’t address the genocide; a sort of a “historical amnesia”. We have no problem pointing the fingers at others who have done such atrocities, but when it comes to ourselves, when we can’t even examine, not to mention document, who we are and what we have done in our own country, it is truly sickening.
Noam Chomsky’s response to the Native American genocide:
” It is not that the people involved didn’t know about it. John Quincy Adams, a great grand strategist, who had a major role in these atrocities, in his later years when he reflected on them, referred to that hapless race of North Americans, which we are exterminating with such insidious cruelty. They knew exactly what they were doing. But it doesn’t matter. It’s us.”
“It’s us.” Us = whites. That kind of says it all doesn’t it?
So…if you are celebrating Thanksgiving today with family and friends, ponder why you are giving thanks. Are you grateful for the genocide, or are you just ignorant when it comes to the facts about Thanksgiving? I HOPE that you are the latter, and if you are…well…now you know.
And perhaps as well, like myself, you will decide that from now on Thanksgiving is not a day for celebrating and giving thanks in the traditional way, but for being grateful for all that you have today.
And today I am grateful for Doug and Lucy, and my entire family, and my dear friends…for all that I have discovered and learned this year – my lessons have brought me joy and sorrow, and I am grateful for both…and for all of you, my readers, who participate in this blog life with me. And a special thank you to you, Zen Lill for continuing to take the time to be a presence here when no one else is able.
I am grateful for so many more things too large to list here. But I do want to say that I am supremely grateful for Obama, for I can only imagine what this world would be like without his leadership.
And lastly, got to throw in some HOPE… :) …Hopefully, some day we will chose to rid ourselves of this “historical amnesia”, and face this atrocity that our ancestors committed, and we as a society accept, by doing nothing to examine and document what we have done. We can not undo what has happened but the Peoples deserve the recognition that this did happen. Until then…
Happy Thanksgiving in a very untraditional way!
To chat with me and share your gratitude or whatever else is on your mind…blog me.
…with gratitude & xoxo…
Lastly, greed over a great story is surfacing from my “loyal”(?) readers. With all this back and forth about who owns what, that appears on my blog, let me reiterate that all material posted on my blog becomes the sole property of my blog. If you want to reserve any proprietary rights don’t post it to my blog. I will prominently display this caveat on my blog from now on to remind those who may have forgotten this notice.
Gratefully your blog host,
michelle
Aka BABE: We all know what this means by now :)
If you love my blog and my writes, please make a donation via PayPal, credit card, or e-check, please click the “Donate” button below. (Please only donations from those readers within the United States. – International readers please see my “Donate” page)
Posted in Health & Well Being, Human Rights and Equality | 15 Comments »


